Nutrient Dense or Energy Dense?
Energy density and nutrient density are important terms to understand when making food choices.
Foods that are energy dense contain a higher number of calories per serving. In contrast, nutrient-dense foods contain a higher level of vitamins, minerals, and other essential nutrients with little or no added sugars or fats that raise calories. Think of the difference between potato chips and a plain baked potato, sweetened yogurt and plain yogurt, or creamed spinach and steamed spinach. Adding fat or sugar to foods increases the calorie content, making these foods more energy dense.
Choosing nutrient-dense foods more often allows us to consume more essential vitamins and minerals that promote good health while avoiding consuming too many calories, which can lead to obesity. At daily calorie levels between 1,200 and 1,800, <10% of the total calorie budget remains after consuming foods that contain all the nutrients we need. By the time you eat all the fruit, vegetables, whole grains, and protein foods your body needs for optimum health, there are only 120-180 calories left each day for sugars and fat for people who need 1,200 to 18,000 calories per day. If we choose energy-dense versions of these foods, for example, eating sweetened canned fruit, vegetables with extra butter or cheese, processed grains like French fries instead of potatoes, and higher-fat protein foods like sausage or deli meats, then we will consume far more calories than we need.
120-180 calories don’t go very far:
12 ounces of regular soda contains 150 calories, all from sugar, while 1 ounce of potato chips contains 155 calories, primarily from fat.
Most nutrient-dense foods, on the other hand, are low in calories. A recent meta-analysis of 13 experimental and observational studies that looked at over 3600 people aged 18 to 66 showed a significant association between consuming low-energy-density foods and body weight. In other words, people who ate more nutrient-dense foods that are naturally low in calories (foods like fresh vegetables and fruit, whole grains, fat-free dairy products, and lean sources of protein) weighed less than people who consumed more foods that were higher in calories and lower in nutrients. Another benefit of nutrient-dense foods is that they are often high in water and fiber, which increase their volume without increasing calories. For example, compare the volume of 100 calories of a raw apple to 100 calories of apple juice. About 2 cups of sliced raw apples contain 100 calories, while 1 cup of unsweetened apple juice contains 113 calories. You’ll feel more satisfied by eating the apples instead of drinking the juice because the total volume of food we consume is the primary reason for satiety. We can eat a larger volume of low-energy, nutrient-dense foods and lose weight while feeling satisfied.
Tips to reduce energy density and increase the nutrient density of your food choices:
Start lunch or dinner meals with a fresh vegetable salad to help you feel more full. Use the least amount of salad dressing as possible. Dressing typically contains 100 calories or more per tablespoon -- the same number of calories as in 14 cups of lettuce.
Eat a piece of fruit before a meal, and you’ll consume fewer calories overall. One study showed that eating a whole apple before lunch reduced calories consumed at that meal by 15% compared to eating applesauce or drinking apple juice.
Choose a broth-based vegetable soup as part of your meal because the extra broth, combined with the fiber in the vegetables, increases satiety with very few calories. One study showed that participants consumed 26% fewer calories and rated themselves as feeling more full after eating a broth-based soup at the beginning of a lunch meal.
When you want something sweet, reach for fresh fruit like a handful of grapes or a small orange. Fruit contains both water and fiber and is a low-energy-density, high-nutrient-density food with various healthful nutrients, including fiber, vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants that promote health with only 60-80 calories per serving.
Choose less processed foods like brown rice instead of white rice, whole grain bread instead of white bread, or whole grain breakfast cereal instead of processed cereal. Whole grain foods contain more fiber, which helps us feel more satisfied after eating, and they also contain more of the naturally-occurring vitamins and minerals in the food.
Instead of purchasing sweetened yogurt that contains more sugar and calories, choose plain yogurt and add your fruit.
Replace energy-dense potato chips with nutrient-dense, low-calorie crunchy raw vegetables high in fiber, vitamins, and minerals. Some fast food restaurants, such as Subway and McDonald’s, offer apple slices instead of chips or French fries to make choosing fruit easier.
By Lynn Grieger, RDN, CDE, CPT, CHWC
References:
The University of Florida IFAS Extension. Energy and Nutrient Density. Wendy J. Dahl and Lauren Foster. http://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/fs176 Published May 2011, Revised January 2015. Accessed 5-18-18.
Practice Paper of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics: Selecting Nutrient-Dense Foods for Good Health. Hingle M, Kandiah J, Maggi An. J Acad Nutr Diet. 2016;116:1473-1479.
USDA Agricultural Research Service. Food Composition Database. https://ndb.nal.usda.gov/ndb/search/list Accessed 5-21-18.
Stelmach-Mardas M, Rodacki T, Dobrowolska-Iwanek J, et al. Link between Food Energy Density and Body Weight Changes in Obese Adults. Nutrients. 2016;8(4):229. doi:10.3390/nu8040229.
https://www.eatrightpro.org/practice/position-and-practice-papers/practice-papers/practice-paper-nutrient-density
Rolls BJ. The relationship between dietary energy density and energy intake. Physiology & behavior. 2009;97(5):609-615. doi:10.1016/j.physbeh.2009.03.011.