Are Ultra-Processed Foods Always Bad?

 
FavoriteLoadingAdd to favorites

If you’re like most Americans, you eat way too many ultra-processed foods. Recent national surveys suggest we get about 57% of our calories from foods that have undergone multiple industrial processing steps or contain ingredients you wouldn’t have in your own home. 

Discovering ultra-processed foods

When you flip over your package of snack cakes and see ingredients like colors, preservatives, and emulsifiers listed, you’ve identified an ultra-processed food. Other favorite ultra-processed foods include BBQ potato chips, candy, ice cream, some breads, some breakfast cereals, and most protein bars. 

Are they harmful?

If 57% of your calories come from snack cakes, candy, ice cream, chips, and cheese puffs, then ultra-processed foods are doing your body harm. In fact, research shows that people whose diets are packed with ultra-processed foods are more likely to gain weight and develop health problems like type 2 diabetes.

But some ultra-processed foods are wholesome choices. So there’s no need to eliminate them all.

By definition (using the common NOVA classification), any food product with industrial ingredients is an ultra-processed food. If your veggie burger is made of soy protein or pea protein, your lunch is ultra-processed. Sipping on a smoothie of health-boosting fruits and vegetables as well as whey protein? The whey protein makes it ultra-processed. If you pour soy milk on your oatmeal, you’ve doused your breakfast with an ultra-processed food. Likewise, if your cornflakes are fortified with fiber or if your plain water is carbonated, they too are ultra-processed. 

The problem with food classifications

The problem is nuance. It’s comfortable – human nature even – to categorize foods, people, emotions, places, and so forth. So often, people put all carbohydrate-rich foods in the same category. But jelly beans and kidney beans have little in common. Similarly, snack cakes and veggie burgers are not the same.

Bottom line: Consider nutrient density when making your food choices. Instead of worrying over specific ingredients or food classification, ask yourself if the food offers you good nutrition. Aim for a yes at least 80% of the time. Your total diet is more important than any single food – unprocessed or ultra-processed.

By Jill Weisenberger, MS, RDN, CDCES, CHWC, FAND

Become a premium member today and get access to hundreds of articles and handouts plus our premium tools!

Upcoming Posts

 

Fun Fruit Trivia: Peaches


August 2022

 
UP NEXT IN Food and Health, Prevention
Could Eating Fish Regularly Raise Your Risk of Skin Cancer?

New Products Available Now

 
Published on Categories articles, prevention, practitioner ideas and news, food and health, nutrition education resources, ingredients, diet and cancer, PremiumTags , , , , , ,