Coffee Creamer Comparison Chart
Click this image to get your handout.
It's time for another reader request!
Anne Linge, RDN, CD, CDE, asked if we have any hacks to make coffee healthier... and her question so inspired us that we're launching a whole coffee series! Today I want to present the first installment: a coffee creamer comparison chart.
Many people don't think much about what they add to their morning coffee, but that choice matters, especially in terms of daily calories, sugar consumption, and saturated fat levels.
Sure, some of the comparisons are a bit obvious -- of course, heavy cream has more calories and saturated fat than whole milk -- but others can be surprising. For instance, did you know that coconut milk has almost as much fat as heavy cream? And that fat-free half-and-half has twice as much sugar as regular half-and-half? Add flavored creamers, nut milk, and other variations to the mix; things can get confusing. Well, they could... but that's why we're here! Let's un-complicate things, shall we?
We'll start with a chart.
My team and I compared the 11 most popular liquids that people are adding to their coffee -- everything from traditional cream to unsweetened almond milk. We explored total calories, fat content, saturated fat content, grams of protein, and sugar levels, then put all of our findings in a handy chart.
Check it out!Wow!Let's look at the winners: almond milk has the fewest calories, while whole milk, pea milk (Ripple), and soy milk are tied for best protein content.
Now let's talk about the ones you should watch out for. Many people assume that coconut milk is heart-healthy, but it's loaded with saturated fat, not to mention calories! Another one to carefully think about is the French vanilla coffee creamer -- with 40 grams of sugar in a dinky half cup, that creamer could throw off your nutrition plan for the whole day!
And speaking of serving size...The packages had lots of different serving sizes listed in their Nutrition Facts. Heavy cream called for a tablespoon, as did the vanilla creamer, while others listed their nutrition information by the cup, like whole milk and almond milk. Many other creamers had a serving size of 2 tablespoons. How could we compare such different amounts?
For the most straightforward evaluation, we decided to compare the same amounts of each creamer. So we did a little math and compared a half-cup serving of each liquid. If you're only using a splash or a dash of one, its impact will be less than if you're pouring a half cup or more.
We pulled the manufacturer's data to get the most accurate numbers. And just between you and me, Ripple is hands-down my favorite. It's a plant-based half-and-half dairy-free alternative made with pea protein. I can cook with it, and I love to use the unsweetened version in soups. Anyway, that wraps up the first installment, but never fear! More is on the way!
We'll follow up with the most healthful ways to prepare coffee, along with a closer look at the health impact of many popular coffee drinks from restaurants like Starbucks and Dunkin' Donuts. We'll also dig into the cost of coffee and address the effects of caffeine.
And if you're looking for more coffee resources, don't miss the sugar comparison chart (do you sweeten your coffee?) and Dr. James J. Kenney's article Coffee or Tea?